27 Comments

Re. your question about what experience has required the most tenacity:

For me it isn’t one but many repeated experiences of my male colleagues making sexist, misogynistic comments to me, for example, “We need more students. How about you get up and table dance to recruit them?” Or, “Why are you here? You really should be home looking after your children.”

Or, regarding a book I was writing, “There aren’t any Black women writers. They’re too busy having too many babies.”

And when I responded with tenacity (and sometimes with anger) to such comments, my male colleagues would just laugh and say “Oh, I was just joking . Don’t you have any sense of humour?”

That’s when my tenacity broke down, and I would just stamp away furiously.

I wonder what I should have done??

P.S. I was the only woman in the department, so I had no other woman to turn to for help in dealing with my sexist male colleagues. I do think it is difficult for a woman to be tenacious in such circumstances.

Expand full comment
author

Patricia,

These psychological abuses you lived through

are extremely painful.

It is highly constructive of you

to bring them to light here

so we all can see what goes on

when weak men feel threatened

simply by the presence of strong women.

Your personal experiences illustrate

that there are many situations

where tenacity alone does not suffice.

You showed admirable tenacity

in not quitting your position.

But shutting the mouths

of misogynists and sexists

(who are usually racists as well)

so you can be free to enjoy

your position in a mostly male environment

is a much tougher challenge.

Let's do a strategic analysis of the assaults

of misogynists.

THEIR GOAL:

These losers despise women.

They have only one mission: to humiliate you.

THEIR TECHNIQUE

They have one primary technique: provocation.

THEIR STRATEGY

They seek to provoke you.

Make you lose your cool.

Lose your professional dignity.

They seek to provoke you into impotent rage

--which is what they believe their Bad Mother

did to THEM from the time they were born.

In their unconscious mind, you ARE their Bad Mother

against whom they now seek to take sadistic revenge.

They seek the sadistic pleasure

of watching you experience a humiliating meltdown

(tears, rage, angry words, stomping, etc.)

It is the sight and sound of you BEING provoked

into tears/rage/angry words/actions

that EQUALS their victory.

It PROVES to them their superior power over you,

the hated and despised Bad Mother.

They feel they have asserted their power over you

--and WON!!!

Their phony show of "power" is a defensive refutation

of their actual weak passive unmanly condition.

HOW TO DEFEAT THEM

Let's look at their provocations

and consider a few potential responses

that would foil their folly:

"We need more students.

How about you get up and table dance to recruit them?”

Delighted, eye to eye response:

"I bet that's how YOU were recruited!

Dumb guys ALWAYS follow their crotch!"

You break into a grin, laughing loudly:

"See? I have a GREAT sense of humor!"

as you stride away with a nonchalant gait.

"Why are you here?

You really should be home looking after your children.”

Dead sober, earnest, eye to eye response:

"YES, Mother.

You are SOOO right.

I really should, Mother.

Otherwise they won't turn out

ALL POWERFUL, like YOU!"

as you walk away

nodding your head in agreement.

“There aren’t any Black women writers.

They’re too busy having too many babies.”

You shake your head sadly,

looking him in the eyes:

"I think YOUR mother had one too many."

as you walk away with a grieving look.

What is happening here?

The key thing is: You. Are. Not. Provoked.

Their entire strategy of provocation

has utterly flopped.

You didn't REACT.

You remained totally above them.

It is obvious by your responses

that they have no power over you whatsoever.

You are enjoying yourself, your life, your freedom,

your strength, your power, your position.

They haven't made a single dent in it.

Your composed and pithy responses

to their pathetic efforts to provoke you

make them look....

RIDICULOUS

WEAK and

IMPOTENT.

Which is precisely what they are.

Expand full comment

Robert Service was a contemporary of Kipling and others. Imperialism and jingoistic nationalism were the order of the day and manliness was celebrated in western culture. He was a product of his time. His poetry endures, especially in Canada and Alaska. "The Cremation of Sam McGee" is a hoot.

Expand full comment
author

Hahaha I read that inspired ballad long ago, Fred

And again just now...

Had forgotten the ending

so it took me by surprise again :)

Service sure knew how to spin

a rich and rowdy yarn

Your stories contain flashes of his grin

Expand full comment
May 4Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

YES!

Thank you for giving me the word to use.

When describing myself, I had been using the word "stubborn."

I knew it was a strength.

Now I see it is actually "TENACITY" that is my strength.

I DO want to see what the end will be.

The goal begins with the idea, with the dream.

You blazed the trail, and now it is a path others can follow.

Thank you!

Expand full comment
author

Yes indeed, Beverly

I can see that TENACITY is the flag

of your own private country.

Mine too, along with AUDACITY :)

We boomers

took to our heart, mind and soul

the ideas and the vision

in JFK's Inaugural Address

and MLK's I Have a Dream.

We are a tenacious lot.

We continue unstoppably living out JFK's words:

Ask not what your country can do for you.

Ask what you can do for your country.

May God bless you, Beverly,

in all your faithful and tenacious service to America

as we rebuild the center,

revive and rebirth our democracy.

Expand full comment
May 4Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

Tenacity has kept me going when it was much easier to quit.

The point of "deciding" is the moment when obstacles and any form of resistance is broken.

I remember watching Nightbirde perform on AGT...very emotional.

Thank you Deborah for this beautiful piece.

Expand full comment
author

You are very welcome, Olusegun.

I am so happy that you found my letter beautiful.

O my, Olusegun,

you give us a totally new and vital insight here!

I never knew this, never thought of this:

"The point of 'deciding' is the moment when obstacles

and any form of resistance is broken."

Obstacles and resistance

are BROKEN.

BROKEN.

BROKEN in the moment of decision!!!

Wow that is powerful insight.

If you ever feel called to deliver a psychological sermon, brother,

you could PREACH on THIS one.

Expand full comment
May 3Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

A certain quote comes to mind "Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not: nothing is more common than unsuccessful men (people) with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not: the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent".- Calvin Coolidge

Expand full comment
author

Ha!

Thank you for this great quote.

Leave it to ol' Calvin to lay it out:

"Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent."

Yes, indeed.

Without tenacity we are screwed.

With it we can do damn near anything.

That's what Coolidge means by omnipotent.

It's a pretty close synonym for unstoppable.

I sometimes think my dreams are grandiose...

except I keep making them real :)

The bigger the vision

the more fun it is

to prove the naysayers wrong.

Expand full comment

https://allpoetry.com/The-Quitter

This poem got me through rough patches. Soulmate has gone so far as to suggest that I am stubborn! Anyone who knows me at all will see that I am persistent. I don't know how she gets it so wrong.

Expand full comment
author

Fred,

Thank you for sharing this poem with us.

I can feel the encouragement

of the poet's words

challenging us not to quit.

I am so glad you had this poem

to strengthen you through rough times.

I take issue only with its title.

"The Quitter" is a sadistic epithet.

The poet must have harbored insecurity

causing him to need to feel superior

by choosing such a cruel title.

None of us is superior

to the person who cannot bear to go on.

Our only response to those who give up

is tenderness and compassion.

We are so sorry they had

more pain than they could bear.

We honor them through

redoubling our own commitment

to keep fighting for life.

Expand full comment
May 3Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

Self visualization is the key for positive progress.

Expand full comment
author

You are right, Stanley.

Thank you for your insight.

SEEING yourself progress

embodies the decision to do so.

Expand full comment
May 3Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

Dr. Deborah: Thank you for the trip down memory lane, and for sharing your inspiring story! I needed a shot of that this Friday morning. I am exhausted and ready for a vacation. I remember repeating the mantra to my daughters, during my single mom years, (when it seemed like it was us against the world at times), “Can’t is NOT a word in our vocabulary!”

Expand full comment
author

Geri,

I can just hear you and see you

declaring your invincible soul

as you taught your daughters

how to live

how to overcome

how to maintain their brave and loving spirit

through everything they would ever face!

Yes they too will get exhausted.

They too will need to take a vacation.

But they too always declare "I CAN!"

I can work AND I can take a vacation :) !!!

Expand full comment
May 5Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

Only five more days until we can hit the road and be reunited again with our beloved family! SO excited & proud! Two college graduates to celebrate! My firstborn daughter & her firstborn son (my first grandson) will be earning their degrees within a week of each other! Thank you for your kind and caring words, Deborah .🙏🏻🌹🎉

Expand full comment
author

O what a glorious road trip and reunion

O what triumphant celebrations

Your daughter AND your grandson

Sweet fruits

of all your loving labors

Life does not get any better than this, Geri

With happy tears

I rejoice for you and with you

Expand full comment
May 3Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

I'll try and make this short. Jan. 12, 1968, I met a young woman, we fell in love and in Nov. she had to return to her home country. We agreed to get together in her country. Various circumstances prevented that meeting and a;though we never stopped thinking about each other, we never saw each other again until 2yrs. after her husband died in 2011. At that point, one of her daughters found me on facebook, her mother contacted me, and after 44 yrs. she came to the US and we married. Her watch word is; I never give up.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for sharing

your great love story with us, geo.

We see the value of tenacity writ large.

The watch word of your beloved wife

expresses her beautiful unstoppable essence.

You both found a gem

and never let go of it.

When the time was right

for it to shine

you shined it with joy.

Expand full comment

Thanks Deborah for that inspiration.

Expand full comment
author

David,

Thank you so much for telling me

that my letter was an inspiration for you.

That is always my goal.

It is deeply encouraging to hear

that I reached my goal this week with you.

Expand full comment
May 3Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

I’m not sure if I’m tenacious. A while ago a Marine gave me the nickname “frogedy.” When I asked him why, he replied, “because you jump into everything.” It’s like listening to a child’s cry of “I want.” I never analyzed a decision, just jumped in to do it! Now at 83 I find that I’ve done it again! A friend from the charity organization Homes For Our Troops is coming to visit me for just a couple of days. I decided on the spot that I didn’t want to send her home with just a hug, so I’m putting on an auction/fundraiser! Most of the items are my own beloved collections, hoping to find new homes for them while I’m still alive. I’ve never done anything like this, and yes feel way over my head, but come this Sunday, come what may, I will have seen it through and have done my best! Is that being tenacious?

Expand full comment
author

O Joanne,

when you ask:

Is that being tenacious?

Herr says it all: You betcha.

You are FAST tenacious.

That Marine named you well.

You are Frogedy.

You don't mull.

You don't meander.

You jump right in.

Over your head?

Of course!

Who wants to jump into a pond

where you hit bottom???

Your JUMP is your decision.

Your motto: All in and gonna win.

Fast tenacity is a rare

and beautiful capability, Joanne.

You go, girl.

Expand full comment
May 6Liked by Dr. Deborah Hall

Thank you so much for your supportive comments. I feel like you are my number one cheerleader! The fundraiser is over, and though we didn’t get the turnout I was hoping for, we did raise a decent amount of money. I was content that I had done my best. Having a wheelchair bound soldier, who received one of the custom built houses from Homes For Our Troops, drive 3 hours to be at this event made one of those lifetime memories. What I wouldn’t advise is to be present at the time your precious belongings are being auctioned off! I realized later that the emotions I were feeling was like being alive at one’s wake! Not a good feeling!

Expand full comment
author

What a powerful lifetime memory, Joanne.

Seeing that wheelchair bound soldier come to this event.

He is living in his very own custom built house

and you are part of giving him this beautiful joy.

We who read this story feel great pride in you

for donating your lifelong treasures

so another person can have new life.

That is pretty close to being an organ donor

and yes it was hard to watch the operation.

No wonder you felt as if you were

attending your own wake!

I wouldn't want to attend mine either.

Mind you, our own funeral is another matter.

Huck Finn and Tom Sawyer attended theirs

with great relish.

They got to hear all the town folk

earnestly weeping

and fervently praising their sainted characters.

It was worth the price of admission

...which alas was a tan hiding

when they were found out.

Expand full comment

You betcha.

Expand full comment